Sorry to wind you up so much Jeremy

Hey that's all great! I think 8v golf motors are the ducks nuts too and your right if all the correct fittings are used then there is no real problem with a k-jet car. No more dangerous than any petrol car really tho I personally hate to much around with most fuel systems and I really hate the rear under car fuel pumps on k jets as the adapter bit often loosens at the pump rather than unbolting from the banjo......I'm sure you will know what I'm talking about Mr VWRally

If were talking about a certain person Im sure they wish they just had there good old 8v that went and went back in there too

But that's life.
I think if you go to the lengths you were saying in the post I made comment regarding mucking around that all the gudgeon stuff is almost at the far end of mucking around .....but sure if you know what your doing and have the bits and the money why not.
You say you have a 165hp 8v 1.8 is it or a 1.6? I think Ive heard its a 1.6 from past discussions. Well factory they are 110hp as we all know and not that much torque but ok. So what have you done to get a hell of a lot more from this car?
I have as you know had a very quick 8v motor which you now own, but in gutless 1.6 form. And it was gutless compared to when it had 2l of Ross race pistons in it. A fail, I should have known.
Then I got Noels 8v race motor, may have gone well on race gas but was dreadful on pump gas no power at all.
I have fitted a 1.8 gti motor too the yellow mk1 sold buy young Audio now owned by new member dave. Well that one was one out of a box that thing honks.
But my ABF with a chipped ECU goes the best by quite a margin and it will run and run with no probs and is very fuel efficient. Nearly all the mk3 gtis still go well even in the 280k range.
It is simple and it is light and it fits easy as pie.
Still has that bloody annoying fuel pump from the k-jet as well

Its up to what people want, many on here scream for the 1.8t as being the best but i don't need that level of power or complication and more to the point I can't afford to do one!
But what I say is that there can be a lot of mucking around for not so much over all gain. If you are going to have an 8v then just leave it as it is and thrash the hell out of it and have a replacement block to fit.
Or if your a guru like you Jeremy do what you know works and have fun.